Compared with its own kind
A card is compared only with cards in the same fee band, the bands on the cards page:
- Free: no annual fee.
- Everyday: annual fee up to ₹1,500.
- Step up: annual fee ₹1,501 to ₹9,999.
- Premium: annual fee ₹10,000 to ₹50,000.
- Super premium: annual fee above ₹50,000.
One standard month
Every card in a band is valued on the same month of spending: ₹18,000 for Free, ₹18,000 for Everyday, ₹25,000 for Step up, ₹83,400 for Premium, ₹2,00,000 for Super premium.
Free and Everyday cards use ₹18,000, the average monthly spend of a credit card in India (₹17,712 in December 2025, from RBI data compiled by CareEdge Ratings). Step up and Premium cards use the spend their own banks most often ask for before they waive the fee: ₹3 lakh a year for Step up and ₹10 lakh a year for Premium, the middle figure across the cards we have read. No Super premium bank prints a waiver, so that band uses ₹2,00,000 a month.
The month is split the way Indians use credit cards: 20% online shopping, 20% utility bills, 17% groceries, 16% everyday spending, 12% travel, 10% fuel, 5% dining. About two thirds of card spending by value is now online (RBI); online, bills and services come first, then supermarkets and grocery; in shops, fuel comes first, then electronics and department stores and grocery; travel agents take about 9% of all spends (2025 category data, as reported by Upstox).
The bank's numbers only
The year is worked out by the same arithmetic as the calculator: the bank's own reward rates, the caps it prints, the spends it excludes, and a point valued only at a rupee value the bank itself states. The annual fee comes off unless the year's spending clears the bank's own waiver.
Milestone and renewal benefits
Milestone benefits the standard year reaches are added in rupees: a voucher or cashback at the rupee figure the bank prints, and bonus points at the same rupee value as the card's other points. Fuel and utility bills are left out of the spend a milestone counts, because many banks do not count them. A renewal benefit is added only in a year the annual fee is actually paid.
Only benefits a bank states plainly are counted. Anything "up to", offers for the first year or the first few days, offers tied to one merchant, category or number of transactions, memberships, lounge visits, tickets and offers that are ending are left out. Where milestones could be tiers rather than steps that add up, only the highest one reached is counted, unless the bank says they add up. So a benefit can only be counted too low, never too high.
Stars
The cards of a band are put in order of what they are worth after the fee. The best of them gets 5 stars and the lowest 1, in half stars between, by place in the order.
When a card is not rated
A card is not rated when its bank's documents leave out a number the rating needs (the annual fee, a base reward rate, or what a point is worth in rupees), when its only nil fee is a limited-period offer, when fewer than 5 cards of its band can be valued, or when its base rate reads above 4% of every rupee spent (no card we have checked pays that much, so the figure waits for a second reading). Business and corporate cards are not rated yet. Nothing is estimated to fill a gap.
What it does not count yet
Welcome benefits (they come once, not every year), lounge visits and how many ways points can be used are listed on every card page but are not in the rating yet. Starworth is not advice: the right card depends on how you spend, and the calculator shows that for your own month.